Welcome back to the Retention Edge.

Once again, I'm bringing you the latest in ecommerce, marketing and retention, helping you stay ahead of the game.

It’s fascinating to see how fast things move right now.

There’s just been a lot of press about Shopify apps, a bunch of apps with security concerns plus people talking online about the flood of vibe-coded apps watering down the app store.

Now Shopify has come out and announced new controls on the app store, including apps automatically getting taken down if they don’t have any installs.

Muse got big in the news. And now every week I’m seeing a new brand that’s blocking this and other agentic shoppers from their site.

This is the way things work now. It doesn’t take months for companies to move. Teams can build and ship faster than ever.

Your business needs to run the same way. Not shipping just for the sake of shipping; not cutting corners, either.

But you need to recognize the kind of bottlenecks that once limited you, and are now gone.

It’s an exciting time to be building.

Here’s what’s in this edition of the Retention Edge:

  • OpenAI opens ChatGPT to brands with claimable profiles, mention and click counts, and a free Business Agent.

  • AI assistants showed shoppers fake or hijacked store sites in up to 15% of answers in a new test, and smaller brands got it worse.

  • AI assistants' share of store orders roughly quadrupled in a year, to about 1 in 100 at the typical store, and most of those buyers are new.

  • eBay appears to block Meta's Muse and other agents, and United won't let them book flights.

  • TikTok Shop launches a $9.99-a-month membership for its top US shoppers, right before BFCM.

Let's get into it.

AI & Agentic Shopping

ChatGPT now lets you claim your brand and see how often it comes up

OpenAI launched Businesses in ChatGPT in beta. Through Business Hub, any eligible business can claim and verify its profile, keep its details current and add product feeds with pricing and availability. Shopify merchants can connect from Business Hub or the Shopify admin, and eligible Shopify products are already in ChatGPT through Shopify Catalog.

Business Hub also shows how many mentions and website clicks you get, plus "discovery topics," the common themes in conversations where your site is cited. US ecommerce brands can publish a Business Agent, a separately labelled chat that answers shoppers' questions using your information. It's free, and you can also sponsor it as the destination for ChatGPT Ads.

The data has limits. You get themes, not transcripts. A mention only counts when ChatGPT references your website, not when it just names your brand, and a click is a click, not a visit or a sale. Still, it's the first first-party view of how your store shows up in ChatGPT, and claiming your profile costs nothing.

AI assistants are pointing shoppers to fake and hijacked store sites

IP protection firm Podqi asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity where to buy 151 brands, including Lululemon, Birkenstock and Le Creuset, and checked 6,795 answers. All three showed "risky" sites: impostors, knockoff sellers, old brand domains someone else had re-registered, and dead domains anyone could buy. Perplexity did so in 15% of answers, ChatGPT in 8% and Gemini in 4%. Those figures include answers that warned shoppers about the site.

Smaller brands got it worse: answers about larger companies had risky sites about half as often. Questions about regional websites caused the most trouble, and the assistants sometimes listed fake regional sites for brands that don't have any. In one answer, Perplexity named the wrong page as Stüssy's official website and called it "the best starting point for guaranteed authentic items."

AI orders roughly quadrupled in a year, and most come from new customers

Enalitica looked at more than 100,000 recent orders from the stores it measures. AI assistants drove about 1.2% of orders in October and November, roughly four times the share in the same months of 2025. At the typical store, that's close to 1 in 100 orders. ChatGPT brought in about 95 of every 100 of them.

Nearly 9 in 10 AI-referred orders came from first-time customers, against about 7 in 10 of all orders. And GA4 only put 41% of those orders in its AI channel. The rest landed under referral, organic, unassigned or direct.

eBay shuts out Meta's shopping agent, and United bans agents from booking

eBay appears to have blocked AI agents, including Meta's Muse, from browsing its listings. eBay said it takes "a selective approach" to third parties and has "restricted agent access in certain cases."

A day later, United said personal AI agents can't book flights on its site. "To be honest, I don't want to create another middleman," CEO Scott Kirby said.

That’s about the closest someone from one of these big brands has come to saying the truth. Yes, there are questions about liability and fraud with agents. But the bigger concern they have is losing control - especially to an agent, who can’t be upsold so easily.

Amazon's shopping agent now takes orders by text, with ads in the replies

Shoppers can now text Alexa for Shopping to search, compare, build a cart and check out. It can also buy automatically when a product hits a target price, and surface other stores' products through Shop Direct. It starts with a small invite-only group in the US, then "millions more" in the coming weeks. Amazon says more than 400 million customers used Alexa for Shopping in the past 12 months.

Digiday reports that Sponsored Products will appear in those text threads, free to advertisers for now. Ads are moving inside the agent conversation, and the brands that joined Shop Direct can now be found and bought from a text message.

The Shopify Beat

Shopify starts cleaning up its App Store, beginning with apps nobody uses

Shopify is taking a stance against app-spam in their ecosystem, now automatically removing any App Store app that still has zero installs after six months. The rule covers apps that are already listed, not just new ones, in immediate effect.

Getting a new app listed is becoming harder too. Developers have to verify their identity first, "so merchants know who's behind the apps they install." They can have only one new app in review at a time, and they can't submit another until every app they've already published has at least 10 installs from active stores on paid plans. Rejected apps face cooldowns that get longer each time a developer resubmits without fixing the problems.

Shopify is making it clear that the quality of the ecosystem matters. Just in time, too, with the explosion of new apps flooding the store in recent months.

Check your apps' security status before Black Friday

The apps page in Settings now shows each app's latest activity and flags security issues, and each app's detail page shows whether it uses expiring tokens and IP restrictions. Developers have until Nov. 20 to turn on an IP allowlist or get flagged.

Worth five minutes before BFCM: open Settings > Apps and ask vendors about anything flagged. The flags can be blunt, too. Judge.me CEO PJ Celis says a few API calls from reactivated stores got his app flagged, and he believes that's why installs dropped over a weekend.

Shop opens to stores that don't use Shopify Payments, with stricter eligibility for everyone

Eligible stores on any payment provider can now appear on Shop and Shop.com and get referral traffic from them. Only Shopify Payments stores can run Shop Campaigns. Eligibility requirements also got tighter, and stores that miss them drop off Shop until they meet them, so check your status in the Shop channel.

Self-serve returns and cancellations can now be set per market

This used to be one store-wide setting, and your existing settings carry over. One catch from Shopify's own post: if you turn on self-serve returns in a market without return rules, buyers there can request returns with no time limit.

Gadget, a platform many Shopify apps run on, is shutting down

Existing apps keep running until March 31, 2027, and no new apps can be built. If you use smaller apps built on Gadget, expect migrations or shutdowns next year. It's worth asking your app vendors where they host.

Platforms and Marketplaces

TikTok Shop launches its own Prime for its best US shoppers

TikTok Shop is offering TikTok Shop Plus to more than 1 million of its most loyal US customers. It costs $9.99 a month after a 30-day free trial.

Members get free shipping on items with a "Plus" badge, an extra 10% off select products, three coupons a month and instant refunds as store credit, up to twice a month. They also get extra coupons during TikTok Shop's BFCM event, which started Wednesday.

If you weren’t already aware that TikTok is trying to become the new Amazon, this is a pretty clear statement of intent.

Amazon raises FBA fees by an average of $0.19 a unit from January 15

The average works out to about 0.8% of the average selling price, but it hides a wide spread. Small standard-size items rise $0.40 on average at $10-50 and $0.70 above $50. Two storage surcharges go away, and some large items get cheaper: Amazon's example is a 65-inch TV box falling from $48.57 to $36.55. The 3.5% fuel and logistics surcharge stays.

October retail sales grew at their slowest pace in nearly a year

Total retail spending rose 0.2% from September to $561.7 billion, according to the CNBC/NRF Retail Monitor, and 3.6% from a year ago. Electronics led, up 9.3% year over year on price hikes, while furniture fell 2.6%.

NRF's Matthew Shay said households are "timing purchases around special offers and sales events." Two weeks before Black Friday, spending is holding up, but shoppers are choosier and waiting for the deal.

DTC Brands

Poppi's founders take on Gatorade with Jetty

A year after selling Poppi to PepsiCo, Allison and Stephen Ellsworth launched Jetty, an everyday hydration drink, at Whole Foods, on Amazon and online at Target. They're self-funding the launch with $2.5 million and plan to raise later. Gatorade holds 61.1% of the US market, per Modern Retail.

The launch leans on influencer gifting kits and a YouTube series following the build. "The first time around, people were really excited to see me win," Ellsworth said. "No one is excited to see me win again."

Funding and M&A

Zipline raises $1.5 billion as Walmart signs on for 300 more drone delivery sites

Zipline raised $1.5 billion at a $21.5 billion valuation. Walmart's new multi-year deal adds 300 sites, and Uber is targeting one million deliveries a day with Zipline by 2029. In October, the median Zipline order arrived 19 minutes after checkout.

Most of that is restaurant and grocery delivery for now, but it keeps raising the speed shoppers compare every store against.

Also This Week

  • Visa forecasts US holiday retail sales up 4.5% - its strongest projection since 2021, though only 1.1% after inflation. Read more →

  • Amazon sets Black Friday Week for Nov. 19-30 - the window every competing promotion will be measured against. Read more →

  • 43% of shoppers deleted or abandoned an email in the past year because they doubted it was real - from a DigiCert survey of 6,000 consumers (DigiCert sells verified-logo certificates). Read more →

  • The FTC says Amazon charged advertisers up to 250% over auction results on Prime Day and Black Friday - new figures from the unredacted complaint; Amazon denies it. Read more →

  • WPBeginner Growth Fund acquires Drip and Sleeknote - more consolidation in email and SMS tools, with no service changes announced. Read more →

  • Firmly raises $15M to plug stores into AI shopping assistants - it runs the merchant side of Mastercard Agent Connect. Read more →

  • Reddit tests AI-built review pages from community threads - another pre-purchase check built from conversations brands don't control. Read more →

  • Etsy tells sellers to message past buyers about its Cyber Specials, then retracts it as spam - a reminder that marketplace customers aren't yours to message. Read more →

  • Starbucks opens its merch store to everyone and launches a TikTok Shop - after a members-only pilot. Read more →

The Social Sphere

What DTC's been talking about on social media this week.

The Shop app is out-selling AI assistants 26 to 1

Kurt Elster tracked $623K in Shop app sales across 10 Shopify stores in October, beating the old record of $466K set last November around Black Friday. One store made about half of it, so it's a record for the channel rather than for every store, but the Shop app still brought in 26 times what ChatGPT and the other AI assistants did.

ChatGPT's best month yet is still 0.11% of traffic

Elster also re-ran his AI traffic numbers for the same 10 stores. ChatGPT sent 7,937 visits in October, up from 59 in August 2024, but that's still 0.11% of this year's traffic, or $181K in sales out of $144.5M.

The big retailers are keeping outside agents at arm's length

Eric Seufert points out that Walmart only lets outside agents reach its platform through its own agent, Sparky, and that both Sparky and Alexa for Shopping show ads. His read: the largest retailers won't let independent agents get between them and their customers, or their ad revenue, so "(third-party) agentic commerce is a mirage."

Reframe the billing reminder and keep subscribers through rebill

Max Sturtevant's team cut churn for a subscription brand that was losing 10-12% of its subscribers in the three days before rebill. They rewrote the billing reminder from "you're about to be charged" to "get excited, here's what's coming" and stopped sending other messages around the rebill date. Churn in that window fell to around 4%.

Your rising CAC may be a ceiling, not Meta

@ron_ecomm argues that rising CAC is often a brand running out of customers it can realistically reach, not Meta getting worse. Past that ceiling, growth comes from people new to the category, shoppers switching from competitors and repeat purchases, which he calls "the actual place where the 'brand' lives and competes."

A new way to build ecommerce mobile apps

The Retention Edge newsletter is brought to you by MobiLoud.

MobiLoud lets ecommerce brands launch custom native apps, powered by the same underlying code as their website.

Once upon a time, businesses used to have two separate builds for mobile and desktop web. Then the tech improved, development processes evolved, and now no one maintains desktop and mobile separately.

The same used to be true for mobile apps. You needed a separate codebase, a whole new framework, to have a native app. You could launch an app, but it would be at the cost of maintaining a separate storefront in parallel to your site.

Not anymore. MobiLoud lets you keep one source of truth, shipping to three unique channels at once: desktop, mobile web, and a native app.

You get all the benefits of a custom, fully native app, with a modern UI built exclusively for app users - without the overhead of running a separate storefront.

It’s the engine behind the VIP channels from brands like John Varvatos, Jack & Jones, Tadashi Shoji and many more.

If you want to learn more about how it works, and see what’s possible, get in touch and book a free preview and consultation now.

That’s all for this week.

I’ll be back in touch soon, with an eye on what’s happening in the ecommerce and retail world, so you can keep yours on growing your business.

Until then,

Pietro and The Retention Edge Team

PS: shoot me a DM on LinkedIn if you’re interested in what a custom mobile app could do for your brand.