Welcome back to the Retention Edge.
I’m back with the latest in ecommerce, marketing and retention, helping you stay ahead of the game.
Here's what's in this edition of the Retention Edge:
A card skimmer rode in on Optimizely's testing script and ran on 178 organizations' websites, eleven days before Black Friday.
ChatGPT and Gemini can now pay at your checkout, while most shoppers still won't hand an agent their card.
Amazon's "World Product Graph" plan would index nearly every product sold online, partly by crawling brands' own sites.
USPS files for higher January rates, an 11% fuel surcharge and a 20% fee on postage mistakes.
Set Active cancels a Black Friday drop projected at more than $10 million rather than sell on backorder.
Let's get into it.
The Security Beat
A card skimmer ran on 178 organizations' websites through Optimizely's testing script
Another high-profile security incident. On Nov. 16, an attacker exploited a flaw in the signup flow of Optimizely Web Experimentation, impersonated customer admins and added malicious JavaScript to their projects. The code ran in shoppers' browsers from Optimizely's own trusted domain. It looked for card numbers, expiry dates and security codes typed into a site's own forms, swapped cryptocurrency wallet addresses and served exploit kits to older iPhones and iPads.
Security researcher Scott Helme of Report URI checked 1,611 Optimizely snippets and found infected scripts belonging to 178 organizations, including IKEA. BleepingComputer saw the script loading on retail sites including Scheels, American Girl and Stamps.com. Optimizely says it closed the flaw the same day and removed all injected code by 22:24 UTC. The investigation is ongoing, and no one has published a count of stolen cards.
Optimizely's incident report tells affected customers to "treat this as a security incident." It also says cards entered in hosted payment iframes, such as Stripe or Adyen, "were not accessible," and that "sites with a strong Content Security Policy (CSP) were protected."
The wider point for any store: a script you added for testing or tracking runs with the same access as your own code, including on pages where customers type their card details.
The Shopify Beat
Apps without an IP allowlist get delisted after Nov. 20
Shopify set the cutoff: public apps that call the Admin API without an IP allowlist are delisted from the App Store and blocked from new installs after Nov. 20 at 11:59 PM ET. Existing installs keep working, and delisted apps are relisted automatically once they comply. Multi-factor authentication on every partner account comes next.
Custom apps that agencies install on stores outside their own organization need an allowlist too: for new installs from Nov. 20, for existing installs from Jan. 1, 2027. If an agency built an app for you, ask them about it before January.
A new Store activity log shows who changed what, going back 18 months
One filterable log now covers changes to products, orders, discounts, themes, apps, staff, payments and settings, and shows whether a staff member, collaborator or app made each one. It keeps up to 18 months of changes, instead of the previous limit of 250 recent events. Find it under Settings > General.
Shopify Analytics now filters more bot traffic in cart and checkout
"Reports that include a human based filter might show a small dip in sessions," Shopify says. Orders, sales and customer data aren't affected. Keep it in mind when you compare BFCM sessions and conversion rates with last year.
Customer accounts now show store credit and recommend products
Store credit appears on every page of customer accounts, and signed-in shoppers who haven't ordered yet see recommendations from your catalog, "ranked using Shopify's understanding of that shopper's preferences." It only works on the latest version of customer accounts, so stores on legacy accounts need to upgrade.
Shopify Tax's free allowance stops resetting each January
From Jan. 1, 2027, Shopify Tax fees are waived until a store reaches 100,000 in lifetime sales, measured in its pricing currency. Stores already past that "won't receive a new annual free discount." Per-order fee rates and existing annual billing caps don't change. For an established store using Shopify Tax, that means paying fees from the first order of the year.
App developers can now pull their own apps with 30 days' notice
The app disappears from the App Store right away and is removed from merchants' stores on the sunset date. Shopify won't email merchants about it; telling them is the developer's job. After Gadget's shutdown, it's one more reason to keep an eye on the smaller apps in your stack.
AI & Agentic Shopping
ChatGPT and Gemini can now pay at your checkout
OpenAI launched ChatGPT Wallet. A user saves a card once, reviews the items, total and card before each purchase, and approves it with Face ID or a fingerprint. The card network then issues a one-time payment token that goes into the store's normal checkout. OpenAI's merchant guide says "No Wallet-specific integration is required," and businesses "keep their customer relationships and control over pricing, fulfillment, returns, and customer service." For now it's limited to ChatGPT Pro subscribers in the US, aged 18 and older, with US-issued cards.
Four days later, Google made Gemini's task mode free in six countries. In the US it can compare products through the Shopping Graph and check out with Google Pay, within a spending cap the user sets.
Both companies say the same thing about the catch. OpenAI warns that "some sites may unintentionally block purchases," and it's working with Forter, Riskified, Sardine, Signifyd, Adyen, Checkout.com and Stripe to help their systems recognize legitimate agent purchases. Google: "For decades, bots were blocked by default because most were malicious." So what decides whether these orders reach you is your bot and fraud settings, not a new integration.
Shoppers trust AI's recommendations, not its hands on their card
In a Salesforce survey of more than 2,500 shoppers in the US, UK, Canada and Australia, 74% said they trust the recommendations AI gives them. But 73% aren't comfortable giving a personal AI agent their payment details, and 49% aren't interested in agents browsing or buying for them at all. Only 19% of people who use a personal agent have used it at checkout.
AI is winning the research. The shopper is still the one entering the card.
Every Shopify store now tells visiting AI agents what they're allowed to do
Sierra released version 1.0 of the Personal Agent Protocol, or "Poppy," and "Shopify has enabled Poppy for every merchant on its platform." It covers how an agent arrives at a store: it says who it is and learns what it can do, as a guest or signed in to the customer's account. Meta's Muse "automatically looks for Poppy first on every site it visits." You don't need to set anything up.
Platforms and Marketplaces
Amazon's internal plan to own the world's product data
Reuters reviewed an internal Amazon document describing a "World Product Graph": data on "virtually every item for sale on Earth, whether Amazon stocks it or not." It depends on learning how brands organize products on their own websites. Some brands contribute data directly, and Amazon would crawl other sites. Reuters couldn't determine whether Amazon would ask permission in all cases.
The document carries "an aspirational future release date of October 1, 2027," and admits "Many Rufus answers are factually wrong or incomplete." Amazon said drafts like this "often paint an incomplete picture" and don't necessarily reflect its current plans.
Either way, your own product pages are the raw material, whether or not you sell on Amazon.
Instagram lets creators tag Amazon products directly in reels and posts
Creators can now add up to 30 Amazon products per reel or 20 per feed post. Once they connect their Instagram and Amazon Influencer accounts, affiliate attribution applies automatically, and the links open the Amazon Shopping app. Instagram told TechCrunch that product links on reels and posts draw about twice as many clicks as links in bio, and it takes no commission.
If you sell on both your own site and Amazon, check which one your creators are tagging.
Amazon has put 40% of its sellers on Haul, most without asking
Haul listings have started showing in Amazon's main search. Marketplace Pulse counts nearly 184,000 sellers with listings in Haul, about 40% of active Amazon.com sellers, and most never signed up: Amazon cross-lists select products already in its fulfillment centers. Sellers pay the same fees, and they can't remove individual products, only opt their whole account out.
Haul has gone from a separate Temu-style store to, in Marketplace Pulse's words, "a price band within Amazon." If you use FBA, check Seller Central for what's been cross-listed.
Shipping and Costs
USPS files for 5.9% higher package rates and an 11% fuel surcharge in January
USPS has asked regulators to raise Priority Mail Express, Priority Mail, Ground Advantage and Parcel Select by an average of 5.9% from January 17, 2027. The temporary 8% charge from April was due to expire that day. Instead, USPS would keep it and add three points, for an 11% fuel surcharge it will review in July 2027.
The filing also adds a 20% fee on postage corrections for wrong weights or dimensions: a seller who underpaid by $5 would owe $6, and one who overpaid by $5 would get back only $4. These are proposals, but it's a good time to check the package weights and dimensions saved in your shipping settings.
Retail Trends
Economic optimism hits its lowest point since the Great Recession
Gallup found that the share of US adults optimistic about the economy fell from 47% last year to 29%, the lowest since it started asking in 2007. October retail sales rose 0.2%, slowing from 0.8% in September. Nonstore retailers, which include online sellers, were up 1.2% on the month, while clothing stores fell 0.7%.
Shoppers are still spending, and they feel bad about prices doing it.
DTC Brands
Set Active cancels a Black Friday drop projected at more than $10 million
The activewear brand, a nearly nine-figure business with 54 employees, hit its annual revenue goal by Q2. Founder and CEO Lindsey Carter says that growth "exposed where our operational infrastructure just couldn't keep up." When it became clear the product wouldn't reach the warehouse in time, she cancelled the launch instead of selling on backorder, and explained it in a statement on her own Instagram: "I wanted them to hear it from me."
The new rule: "Effective immediately, we will only launch products that are physically in our warehouse, counted, and quality checked." The site's Black Friday sale is still running; just with products they can count on being able to fulfill.
Quince is turning into a wholesale door for other brands
Quince now buys third-party brands outright, starting with Therabody and adding Supergoop, Fresh, Foreo, Staub, Fellow and East Fork. Customers get 25% back in Quince credit on eligible beauty purchases, which keeps the next order at Quince. Cadence, which joined in October, says Quince "has far surpassed any other retailer that we've worked with, just in size and velocity."
"The goal isn't to offer customers endless choice," said Quince's Dakota Kate Isaacs.
Also This Week
Amazon will count display ad impressions only when they render, from Jan. 1 - it estimates 63% fewer reported impressions, so CPMs will look higher and old benchmarks won't compare. Read more →
Amazon extends its 3.5% fuel and logistics surcharge to AWD and Multi-Channel Distribution from Feb. 1 - about 17 cents a unit on average, per Amazon. Read more →
Andy Jassy says Amazon hasn't ruled out letting outside AI agents shop its site - "it has to be a fair exchange of value." Read more →
Amazon's Review Requests ads reach buyers 7 to 150 days after delivery - open beta in the US, for products with fewer than 1,000 ratings and reviews. Read more →
Bloomreach acquires AthenaHQ - a startup that helps brands show up in AI chatbot answers; terms weren't disclosed. Read more →
ThredUp starts TikTok Shop livestreams from its distribution centers - three in four shoppers in its first six shows were new to ThredUp. Read more →
BigCommerce rolls out Shopping Agent - an on-site AI assistant merchants can customize, reaching eligible stores before the holidays. Read more →
Meta adds a 6-second option for ThruPlay - the default stays 15 seconds, so cost per ThruPlay at the two settings won't compare. Read more →
UK retailer Gear4music blames lower paid-search traffic, partly on AI search results - revenue is down 13% so far in its third quarter, and its shares fell more than 30% on the news. Read more →
Zipify's study of 16,600 Shopify stores: pre-checkout upsell pop-ups convert at 13.3%, post-purchase offers at 8.7% - data from Zipify's own app users. Read more →
What DTC's been talking about on social media this week.
SourceMedium's live BFCM benchmarks are back
SourceMedium is publishing daily BFCM benchmarks again: year-over-year shifts in sales, discounts, marketing and support across categories like apparel, home goods and CPG, updated every morning through Cyber Monday. Feifan Wang posts the highlights on LinkedIn as they come in. Last year's numbers were one of the most useful things I checked during the season, because they show whether a slow day is your store or everyone's.
Do the math before you put 40% off everything
Joe Marston ran the numbers on an example from a peak-season playbook: a brand that breaks even at 2.0x ROAS at full price needs 4.5x at 40% off, so its ads have to work 2.25 times as hard just to avoid losing money. Discount when the numbers work, not because everyone else is.
Put January's returns in your BFCM forecast now
Taylor Sicard sums it up in five words: "BFCM orders become January returns." Count the cost of processing those returns, and of the items you can't resell at full price, in your forecast now, before they arrive.
"Too expensive" can mean three different things
When subscribers cancel because it's "too expensive," Thomas Lalas says to read the sub-reason before reaching for a discount. "I found a cheaper alternative" is a price problem, "I don't use it enough" is an onboarding problem, and "I can't afford it right now" is a budget problem, better met with a skip option or a commitment offer.
Fix your product data before you plan for agents
Asked about agentic shopping on a discovery call, @jaketheadnerd gave a simple answer: sellers "should worry less about being agent-ready (for now) and more about whether AI actually understands what you are selling." Shoppers are using AI for advice and still buying for themselves, so the budget should go into your own site's product data first.
A new way to build ecommerce mobile apps

The Retention Edge newsletter is brought to you by MobiLoud.
MobiLoud lets ecommerce brands launch custom native apps, powered by the same underlying code as their website.
Once upon a time, businesses used to have two separate builds for mobile and desktop web. Then the tech improved, development processes evolved, and now no one maintains desktop and mobile separately.
The same used to be true for mobile apps. You needed a separate codebase, a whole new framework, to have a native app. You could launch an app, but it would be at the cost of maintaining a separate storefront in parallel to your site.
Not anymore. MobiLoud lets you keep one source of truth, shipping to three unique channels at once: desktop, mobile web, and a native app.
You get all the benefits of a custom, fully native app, with a modern UI built exclusively for app users - without the overhead of running a separate storefront.
It’s the engine behind the VIP channels from brands like John Varvatos, Jack & Jones, Tadashi Shoji and many more.
If you want to learn more about how it works, and see what’s possible, get in touch and book a free preview and consultation now.
That’s all for this week.
I’ll be back in touch soon, with an eye on what’s happening in the ecommerce and retail world, so you can keep yours on growing your business.
Until then,
Pietro and The Retention Edge Team
PS: shoot me a DM on LinkedIn if you’re interested in what a custom mobile app could do for your brand.

